BRD Medical College MBBS Case: 3 Students Stuck for Up to 20 Years Amid NMC Rule Confusion
BRD Medical College MBBS Limbo: 3 Students Stuck for Up to 20 Years as NMC’s 9-Year Rule Clashes with MCI-Era Admissions
Updated: March 27, 2026
BRD Medical College Gorakhpur: 3 MBBS Students Face 20-Year Academic Limbo
In a highly unusual and troubling development, three MBBS students of BRD Medical College, Gorakhpur, have remained stuck in the medical course for up to 20 years, as the National Medical Commission (NMC)’s current 9-year MBBS completion rule conflicts with admissions made during the earlier Medical Council of India (MCI) era.
The students, belonging to the 1998, 2009, and 2010 MBBS batches, were admitted under the old MCI framework, which did not impose a strict maximum time limit for completing the MBBS course. However, with the implementation of new NMC regulations, their academic future has become uncertain, leaving them in a prolonged state of limbo.
BRD Medical College Students Stuck in MBBS for 20 Years
BRD Medical College MBBS Students Case Overview
Section
Details
Article Title
Why Are BRD Medical College Students Stuck in MBBS for 20 Years?
College Name
BRD Medical College, Gorakhpur
Issue
Three MBBS students are reportedly stuck in completing their medical degree for up to 20 years due to academic failures, pending results, delayed supplementary exams, and regulatory confusion.
Key Reason
Clash between MCI-era admissions and the NMC 9-year MBBS completion rule.
Affected Batches
1998, 2009, and 2010 MBBS batches
Main Concern
Whether NMC’s 9-year MBBS completion rule can be applied to students admitted before the National Medical Commission came into force in 2020.
Current Status
One student has received result after High Court intervention and is allowed to appear in supplementary exams; two students are still awaiting result declaration.
Authority Involved
BRD Medical College, University, National Medical Commission (NMC), High Court
Why This Matters
This case may become a major precedent for legacy MBBS students across India who were admitted under the old Medical Council of India (MCI) rules.
Why Are BRD Medical College Students Unable to Complete MBBS on Time?
Reason
Explanation
Failure in MBBS Subjects
Some of the students reportedly failed in certain MBBS professional examinations, preventing academic progression.
Delayed Supplementary Exams
Supplementary exams were either delayed or not conducted in a timely manner, prolonging the academic timeline.
Pending Result Declaration
Results of some students remained pending for years, creating uncertainty about eligibility for the next step.
Administrative Hurdles
Institutional and university-level procedural delays added to the prolonged academic limbo.
Regulatory Confusion
Transition from MCI rules to NMC regulations created ambiguity about which rule applies to old admissions.
Lack of Transition Policy
No clear rule was available for handling extremely long-pending MBBS cases admitted before 2020.
NMC 9-Year MBBS Completion Rule Explained
NMC Rule
Details
Maximum MBBS Duration
MBBS students must complete the entire course within 9 years from the date of admission.
First-Year Attempts Limit
A student is allowed a maximum of 4 attempts in the first year under the updated rules.
Progression Requirement
Students must satisfy progression criteria under the Competency-Based Medical Education (CBME) framework.
Regulatory Authority
National Medical Commission (NMC)
Effective Framework
Applied under the post-2020 medical education regulatory structure
Why It Matters in This Case
The rule is stricter than the earlier MCI framework and may conflict with legacy admissions.
One BRD Medical College Student Gets Result After High Court Order
Point
Details
Legal Action Taken
One student approached the High Court for release of long-pending MBBS result.
Court Direction
The High Court directed the concerned authorities to declare the result.
Outcome
BRD Medical College declared the student’s result.
Result Status
The student reportedly failed again in two subjects.
Current Relief
The student has been allowed to appear in supplementary examinations.
Next Opportunity
If the student clears the supplementary exams, he may still complete the MBBS degree after years of delay.
Two Other BRD Medical College MBBS Students Still Await Results
Point
Details
Students Pending
Two MBBS students are still awaiting their result declaration.
College Position
BRD Medical College authorities said discussions are underway with the university.
Administrative Status
Official communication is reportedly in process.
Possible Outcomes
They may either be declared pass or be allowed to appear in supplementary examinations.
Importance of Result
Their result status will determine whether they can legally and academically complete the MBBS course.
BRD Medical College’s Stand on the MBBS 20-Year Case
Statement / Position
Details
Principal’s Name
Ramkumar Jaiswal
College Position
The college says it is bound to follow the latest NMC regulations.
Institutional Difficulty
Students were admitted under MCI-era rules, but NMC rules are now in force.
Main Problem
No simple or direct transition guideline exists for such extraordinary long-pending cases.
Action Taken by College
BRD Medical College has reportedly approached the National Medical Commission (NMC) for clarification and directions.
Earlier BRD Medical College Case: Student Stuck in 1st Year for 11 Years
Section
Details
Earlier Incident
BRD Medical College had previously sought NMC clarification for another student stuck in the first year of MBBS for 11 years.
Background
That student reportedly failed an MBBS exam in 2015 and could not progress.
Why It Was Important
It raised concerns over delayed exams, legacy admissions, and the applicability of new NMC rules to old students.
Relevance to Current Case
Shows that the present issue is not isolated and reflects a broader regulatory gap.
MCI vs NMC: Key Difference in MBBS Completion Rules
Regulation
MCI Era
NMC Era
Maximum MBBS Completion Duration
No clearly enforced strict cap in many legacy cases
9 years from date of admission
First-Year Attempt Limit
Flexible / institution or university dependent
Maximum 4 attempts
Regulatory Authority
Medical Council of India (MCI)
National Medical Commission (NMC)
Applicability
Mainly pre-2020 admissions
Post-2020 medical education framework
Transition Clarity
Limited formal closure rules in old cases
Stricter framework, but legacy transition remains unclear
Core Legal Issue in the BRD Medical College MBBS Case
Legal Question
Explanation
Main Legal Issue
Can the NMC 9-year MBBS completion rule be applied retrospectively to students admitted under the MCI-era system?
Why It Matters
If applied retrospectively, these students may become ineligible to complete MBBS despite pending academic processes.
Why It’s Complex
The students were admitted before NMC replaced MCI in 2020, so retrospective application may be challenged legally.
Possible Resolution
NMC clarification, university decision, or further court intervention may settle the issue.
What Happens Next for the 3 BRD Medical College MBBS Students?
Possible Next Step
Impact
University Declares Pending Results
Will clarify whether the students are pass/fail and eligible for further action.
Supplementary Exam Permission
Could give students another chance to clear remaining subjects.
NMC Clarification
May determine whether legacy students can be exempted from the 9-year rule.
Court Intervention
If relief is denied, students may seek legal remedy through the High Court or other judicial forums.
Final Outcome
Students may still complete MBBS if permitted to clear pending papers under a special interpretation or relief.
Why This BRD Medical College MBBS Case Matters Across India
Broader Issue
Why It Matters
Legacy MBBS Students
Many students admitted under old rules may face similar confusion.
MCI to NMC Transition
Highlights the absence of a clear transition framework for old admissions.
Administrative Delays
Shows how delayed results and exam systems can affect a student’s entire career.
Policy Gap
Suggests the need for a special policy for extraordinary long-pending MBBS cases.
National Impact
This case could become a landmark precedent for MBBS duration rules in India.
Conclusion
The case of three BRD Medical College MBBS students stuck for up to 20 years highlights a serious gap in India’s medical education transition from MCI to NMC.
While the NMC’s 9-year cap on MBBS completion aims to bring discipline and uniformity to medical education, its clash with MCI-era admissions has created an exceptional hardship for students whose cases remain unresolved due to failed subjects, delayed exams, and pending results.
With one student already allowed to take supplementary exams after a High Court order, and two others still awaiting results, all eyes are now on the university and the National Medical Commission for a final resolution.